ESG in Agribusiness: what is it, why is it important now, and what can I do?

Lorem ipsum
  • Blog
  • 5 minute read
  • November 21, 2023

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations continue to grow increasingly vital for Australian agribusinesses. Meeting specific ESG criteria is becoming the difference between inclusion and exclusion from Australian lenders, supermarkets, other retailers, consumers, investors, and local and export markets.  

 

Changing expectations around ESG present challenges for those agribusinesses slower to adapt to them. However, there are multiple opportunities for growth for those who fully understand ESG and how best to turn it to their advantage.

What is ESG exactly?

ESG encompasses three main areas, as seen under each pillar below. In short,

  • Environmental: involves factors like climate change, greenhouse gas emissions, natural resources and regenerative agriculture, water stress and conservation, biodiversity, pollution, and waste.
  • Social: animal welfare, nutrition and health, sustainable sourcing, your reputation in local communities, employee engagement and well-being.
  • Governance: refers to the systems and processes used to make decisions, manage operations, and interact with stakeholders. It focuses on responsible, ethical conduct, transparency and maintaining trust - with employees, customers, investors and the community.

Climate change — and measuring emissions — is the cornerstone of the environmental pillar and essential to any ESG efforts. It's one of the most immediate factors needing action and the one we get asked about most. It's worth explaining in some depth. 

The Greenhouse Gas Protocol ('GHG Protocol') is the main global standard for carbon accounting. The GHG Protocol Agricultural Guidance focuses on how this is to be interpreted by the agricultural sector. It breaks down emissions into three Scopes:

Scope 1: direct GHG emissions from sources owned or controlled by you or your farming operation, including methane from cattle, nitrous oxide from fertiliser, and emissions from mechanical equipment and company vehicles.

Scope 2: indirect emissions from the generation of purchased energy, like electricity used on your farm. 

Scope 3: indirect emissions in your supply chain, such as emissions associated with procurement, transport, product use, and end-of-life disposal. These usually make up the most significant portion of the carbon footprint.

It’s important to note that Scope 1 and 2 emissions will often form a substantial part of the Scope 3 inventories for downstream processors and retailers of agricultural products, as well as upstream suppliers of farm inputs such as seed and fertiliser. The significance of this is that failure to reduce 1 and 2 emissions can negatively impact your supply chain, market access and product value.

Why is it important now?

The Australian Government has legislated an emissions reduction target of 43% below 2005 levels by 2030, and committed to Australia reaching net-zero emissions by 2050. This is not far away. These targets introduce new requirements across the agricultural supply chain from farm gate to plate. 

Additionally, Australia is in the process of adopting mandatory climate reporting standards, based on the recently released International Sustainability Reporting Standard IFRS S2. These are expected to apply from as early as July 2024 to large companies, and extend to all financial reporting entities over the following three years.

For those keeping an eye on this evolving landscape, there is potential to maximise new opportunities while mitigating any exposure to:

While Australia's ESG requirements are not as stringent as the EU's, enhancing your green credentials and reducing GHG emissions to align with European rules — such as the newly issued Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) — will reduce the risk of tariffs and improve your competitiveness. While this policy currently affects only a few sectors, such as steel, fertiliser, hydrogen and electricity, it could extend to other sectors, including beef, cotton and wool. This could mean having to fundamentally change your farming practices, such as how chemicals are used. Choosing not to adapt to such a regulation could become a trade barrier for buyers of your products.

Banks are increasingly tying lending criteria to agriculture emission reduction and other ESG KPIs. This means that positive ESG behaviour opens access to sustainability-linked loans. On the flip side, non-compliance could limit access to loans and finance for farms and for agribusinesses across the supply chain, as well as access to capital from equity investors, as discussed below.

Investors and shareholders are integrating ESG considerations into their strategies, which can lead to superior valuations for businesses that align with ESG principles. Our latest Global Private Equity Responsibility Investment Survey showed that, over the past ten years, Private Equity firms have radically reassessed the importance of ESG to their businesses, shifting ESG from a compliance exercise to an overarching framework to inform investment choice, fund strategy and business transformation.

Consumers are seeking more transparency and traceability in the products and services they buy, with some willing to pay a premium for sustainably and ethically farmed products.

Major customers like Fonterra, Coles, and Woolworths are investing in ESG programs to align with EU regulations and the Paris Agreement. They are setting their own emissions reduction targets while also shifting expectations for their suppliers – such as greater transparency and traceability - in a bid to reduce their Scope 3 emissions and achieve carbon-neutral agriculture. For farmers, this means providing data proving products meet EU ESG standards — whether that be for grain, meat, dairy or fibre. For example, Fonterra recently increased its carbon emission reduction target, this is impacting NZ dairy farmers upstream who now must reduce their on-farm emissions to maintain market access.

Changes in regulations, such as New Zealand's proposed 'cow tax', Canada's planned fertiliser tax, Netherlands livestock buyouts and taxes on nitrogen fertilisers across Europe, highlight the shifting sands of global regulation. Australia exports around 72% of agricultural production, making farming vulnerable to policy shifts, whether the effect is indirect or not.

72%

Australia exports around 72% of agricultural production, making farming vulnerable to policy shifts, whether the effect is indirect or not.

What can I do?

The key message here is that ESG represents changing expectations for agribusinesses like yours around how you produce, sell your product, and even how you communicate. Transparent communication about your ESG initiatives is essential. You need to document and openly discuss your sustainable practices and commitment to ESG principles to satisfy market expectations. This is especially important given the growing number of consumers willing to pay extra for environmentally and socially responsible choices. 

The increasing importance of ESG is creating new value-creation opportunities for Australian agribusinesses who understand what it is, what ESG factors are most relevant to them, how best to implement effective methodologies, and how best to measure and communicate their progress. We delve into this in more detail throughout our series.

Conversely, for those slower to adapt, ESG presents a challenge, as non-compliance can jeopardise market access and erode value. 

Where are you on this journey? Are you turning ESG challenges into opportunities for growth? 


If you would like to talk to a PwC advisor about your ESG strategy, get in touch. We can help with a decarbonisation strategy, emissions accounting, and ESG reporting and governance frameworks.


Contact us

Kushal Chadha

Kushal Chadha

Partner, Deals Strategy & Operations, PwC Australia

Tel: +61 451 318 703

Hide